Вход на сайт

Просмотр новости

Найдите то, что Вас интересует

I’d even go as far as saying that writers whom everyone has deemed progressive deserve to have their…

Дата публикации: 16-10-2026 13:53:24

hagiomoto:hagiomoto:I’d even go as far as saying that writers whom everyone has deemed progressive deserve to have their work examined and scrutinized more rigorously than that of apolitical or reactionary writers. When people place that much value on their work and the person behind it, it’s all the more important to examine them thoroughly rather than simply accepting them as progressive just because your most leftist friends say so.I think that’s the wrong question. What even makes a novel progressive? The term can mean anything to anyone. My point is that when a writer is promoted as a voice of subversion, or their fiction is assumed to be good simply because they’re leftists, it’s our “duty” to see whether the work lives up to those claims. Being leftist doesn’t, in itself, make someone a good writer, just as writing about social struggles or political causes doesn’t automatically make a novel subversive or artistically accomplished. These claims should be examined rather than taken at face value simply because a writer shares our politics. At the same time, questioning a novel’s progressive credentials is not the same as arguing that it’s morally wrong to read or appreciate works that don’t align with our values.

Основное содержимое страницы с новостью.

Oct 16, 2026

477 notes

hagiomoto:

hagiomoto:

I’d even go as far as saying that writers whom everyone has deemed progressive deserve to have their work examined and scrutinized more rigorously than that of apolitical or reactionary writers. When people place that much value on their work and the person behind it, it’s all the more important to examine them thoroughly rather than simply accepting them as progressive just because your most leftist friends say so.

image

I think that’s the wrong question. What even makes a novel progressive? The term can mean anything to anyone. My point is that when a writer is promoted as a voice of subversion, or their fiction is assumed to be good simply because they’re leftists, it’s our “duty” to see whether the work lives up to those claims.

Being leftist doesn’t, in itself, make someone a good writer, just as writing about social struggles or political causes doesn’t automatically make a novel subversive or artistically accomplished. These claims should be examined rather than taken at face value simply because a writer shares our politics.

At the same time, questioning a novel’s progressive credentials is not the same as arguing that it’s morally wrong to read or appreciate works that don’t align with our values.

Reblogged from sivavakkiyar

Схожие новости

#Наименование новостиТональностьИнформативностьДата публикации
1“gender is a social construct”: fairly easy for leftists to understand05.1601-02-2026
2I know we talk a lot about the literacy crisis and the horrible anti-intellectualism happening rn…020.6518-08-2026
3hello my mutual!!! in my moment of greatest need i supplicate to either you or your followers whether you have read anything responding to the poststructuralists’ points on language, either through a more contemporary trans/otherwise genderweird lens or a postcolonial one. this is after reading cixous’ three steps on the ladder of writing+derrida’s signature, event, context and thinking there’s gotta be more than this.08.1616-10-2026
4only thing that comes to mind today.017.0908-10-2026
5in the midst of capitalism, fanfiction and archive of our own are always unconditionally and…015.8111-08-2026
6Hey, if you’re disabled (of any kind), Mad/Insane, or “undiagnosed but there’s definitely something…017.923-09-2026
7i’m going a little crazy with the plagiarism-and-intertextuality thing. what do i do? if i write in…05.8615-10-2026
8The incompetence is the plan. Corporations need regulations lifted and penalties eliminated.021.3731-07-2026
9The trope where people don’t recognize each other because it’s been so long since they last…014.6316-10-2026
10Did that woman NOT care that ICE murdered her daughter?!022.7624-09-2026

Классификация: Мнения. Схожих патентов: 0. Схожих новостей: 10. Тональность: 0. Информативность: 8.02. Источник: fatehbaz.tumblr.com.